Thursday
July 29, 2010


News
Calendar
Viewpoints
Editorials
Letters
Ken Trainor
Shrubtown
Lifelines
Sports
Journal Plus

Blogs

Community Guide
Special Sections

About Us
Feedback
Send us letters



Legal Notices






Search


Advanced Search

home : viewpoints : viewpoints

3/4/2008 10:00:00 PM Email this articlePrint this article 
Torture just turns us into barbarians

TOM DECOURSEY - ONE VIEW

One of the most important and timely books published in 2006 is ironically a complete and authoritative English translation of Malleus Maleficarum*, often called "The Hammer of Witches," which was first published in 1486.


This treatise documents the medieval Inquisition, which predated the Spanish and Roman Inquisitions, and began roughly with the papal bull of 1199 by Pope Innocent III, in which heresy was equated with treason and thus awarded the death penalty. There is a magnificent introduction by translator Christopher Mackay.


Why is this 520-year-old book so important today? We stand at a crossroads of modern civilization. The Bush Administration as well as Republican presidential candidate John McCain openly espouse the legitimacy of the use of torture, based on two fundamental claims.


First, they assert that our enemies are more evil than any previously encountered, and therefore we are justified in jettisoning two centuries of enlightenment in which the
United States of America was morally superior to any despotic regime that would stoop to the barbaric practice of torture.


Second, they claim that torture is effective in extracting truthful information. Both claims are prima facie preposterous. The brilliance of Malleus Maleficarum is that it reveals with clarity that dark aspect of human nature that is not simply capable of employing torture, but which is capable of doing so in a calculated, premeditated and intentional manner.


For 250 years, the medieval inquisitors used torture and the threat of torture to extract detailed "confessions" out of accused witches. The crimes for which witches were tortured and often burned to death were performing magic, which no modern American would for one second believe is real. The inquisitors believed that a Satanic sect existed, comprised of individuals whose goals were to conduct several hallmark crimes that defined witchcraft, including flying through the air to attend rituals with other witches, sexual relations with the devil, performing magic, renouncing the Church, and killing babies.


There is no evidence that any such sect ever existed, and to the modern mind, most of the activities that define witchcraft are physical impossibilities. That human beings were tortured and killed by representatives of the Church for these imaginary crimes attests to the power of mass delusion, especially when it is reinforced by authorities like the Church, universities or the government.


That thousands of individuals confessed in great detail to crimes that we know today are supernatural fantasies shows the power of torture to extract false confessions that the victim hopes will end the torture, and which reflect more closely the torturer's delusions than any reality.


It is to be hoped that the
United States moves forward into the 21st century. However, we are perilously close to regressing 800 years into medieval barbarism.


* Malleus Maleficarum. 2006. Edited and translated by Christopher S. Mackay.
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.





Reader Comments


Posted: Monday, March 10, 2008
Article comment by: Dagher Marie-Claire

I am currently reading several interviews of Noam Chomsky. They are so rich in information on how medieval barbarism has infected the United States since many many years. He explains among many other things, that generating fear is the best way to control people, how democracy is transgressed so often, how the human rights definition is used only unidirectionnally (they apply to us, but not to our ennemies)...

I am sorry to cite only one reference, but so well documented, and so incredible (viewed from France)!


Posted: Saturday, March 08, 2008
Article comment by: Austin Elliott

Hear hear to the article and to David Colquhoun's comment.

One of the great sadnesses of the "War on Terror" is to see Enlightenment values, centuries of democratic tradition, and the basic rights of citizens being abrogated - and all on the ludicrous premise that our current enemies are uniquely dangerous in a way that the 45 yr Cold War nuclear stand-off with the Soviet Union was not.

Here in Britain I studied US history for a full year in (English) high school. It left me with the firm belief that the US constitution, the rights of the people that it enshrines, and the separation of powers, are among the greatest achievements of human progress. The idea of throwing away the very things that make Western democratic systems something to be proud of, simply because we are terrified of Muslim bogeymen, is truly tragic.


Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2008
Article comment by: David Colquhoun

Viewed from London, articles like this restore the faith of Europeans in the innate decency of the US people. Thanks for publishing it.

Article Comment Submission Form
Please feel free to submit your comments.

Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the Web site editor reviews and approves it.

Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number and e-mail address are for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
Name:
Telephone:
E-mail:
Passcode: This form will not send your comment unless you copy exactly the passcode seen below into the text field. This is an anti-spam device to help reduce the automated email spam coming through this form.

Please copy the passcode exactly
- it is case sensitive.
Message:
   






Copyright 2010, Wednesday Journal, Inc.,
141 S. Oak Park Ave., Oak Park, IL 60302, 708-524-8300

To view any of the publications owned and operated
by Wednesday Journal, Inc., click on the appropriate title.

Forest Park Review · Riverside Brookfield Landmark
Chicago Journal · Skyline · Austin Weekly News · Chicago Parent magazine


Copyright 2010, Wednesday Journal Inc.

Software © 1998-2010 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved